SPOILER: Review of IWTB

[Guest Laurent.]

Links to any reviews without spoilers would be really appreciated as I forgot my Haven account and it looks hard to get one these days. Thanks.

[HighPlainsDrifter]

Links to any reviews without spoilers would be really appreciated as I forgot my Haven account and it looks hard to get one these days. Thanks.

I dont have the link but i recieved an email with a review to the movie and i was surprised to read this guy's views on this movie. His review was very positive, he talked about how this story is actually about Mulder and Scully's relationship. I dont want to say amymore but he gave the movie a good review. He says the X-File Fan will be satisfied

[Orodromeus]

ALL negative reviews from the French press and one from the UK were removed from their respective sites today in an oh-so-obvious move of Fox to limit the damage being done. You can go check. The only positive review left is this one (spoilers as well): https://www.moviehole.net/2008/07/21/the-x-...ant-to-believe/

A Spanish (https://www.muchocine.net/criticas/6887) and a Greek (https://myfilm.gr/article2762.html) review, both negative, were left intact. People in the US have seen it but I believe a non-disclosure agreement was signed so that their reviews would not be posted until the day of the opening. Evidently the European press was not party to that.

I don't really have anything non-spoiler to post. There are some fan reactions, which are more positive, on Haven, but not reviews per se.

[Guest Laurent.]

ALL negative reviews from the French press and one from the UK were removed from their respective sites today in an oh-so-obvious move of Fox to limit the damage being done. You can go check. The only positive review left is this one (spoilers as well): https://www.moviehole.net/2008/07/21/the-x-...ant-to-believe/

A Spanish (https://www.muchocine.net/criticas/6887) and a Greek (https://myfilm.gr/article2762.html) review, both negative, were left intact. People in the US have seen it but I believe a non-disclosure agreement was signed so that their reviews would not be posted until the day of the opening. Evidently the European press was not party to that.

I don't really have anything non-spoiler to post. There are some fan reactions, which are more positive, on Haven, but not reviews per se.

Fox can do that? Force the removal of professional, independent, negative reviews?

[Orodromeus]

I believe they can. The media may be independent, they are in close contact with the industry from which, after all, they make their living on. Fox just has to present this more like following the director's whishes of secrecy rather than censorship, and the media will abide.

The word is out though. There are plenty of Australian reviews, mostly positive, out there. The only US review is the (negative) review of Ain't it cool. I believe the US press is still tied with a non-disclosure agreement till the release (AICN always tries to be the "rebel" of the bunch).

[Blackoil]

Yup, Australian reviews were very positive.